The idea is barely believable, but the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) has confirmed that it is studying this controversial concept. According to the Wall Street Journal, the show would feature immigrants, already in the legal immigration process, competing to prove they are "the most American." Each hour-long episode would see one contestant eliminated. The show would kick off on Ellis Island, a historic symbol of the arrival of millions of immigrants to the United States.
Among the planned challenges, detailed in a 36-page presentation, are a "gold rush" where competitors would extract the precious metal from a mine in California, and the team assembly of a Model T Ford chassis in Detroit. Tests on American history and science would also be included. Contestants would travel across the country by train, and a seat would be removed after each elimination. To host the show, producers are suggesting famous naturalized American personalities such as Sofia Vergara, Ryan Reynolds, and Mila Kunis.
The project, which has already sparked an outcry and comparisons to The Hunger Games saga, is led by Canadian-American producer and author Rob Worsoff (known for Duck Dynasty). His idea is not entirely new, as it had already been unsuccessfully submitted under the Obama and Biden administrations. But today, in a particularly tense political climate over immigration issues under the Trump administration, the proposal is resurfacing and seems to be receiving a more attentive ear.
"Not a Hunger Games for immigrants"
Rob Worsoff defends himself against any cynicism, telling the Wall Street Journal that the show is intended to be "positive" and a "celebration of what it means to be an American citizen." "We're not talking about a Hunger Games for immigrants," he insists, specifying that the losers would not be deported. The stated objective? "Rekindling Patriotism and Civic Duty.".
For the Department of Homeland Security (DHS), spokeswoman Tricia McLaughlin confirmed that the proposal was "in the very early stages of the vetting process" and that it "has not been approved or rejected." She noted that the department receives hundreds of program proposals each year. The DHS statement added: "We must rekindle patriotism and civic duty in this country, and we are happy to review proposals that are out of the ordinary.".
However, DHS Secretary Kristi Noem, known for her media-friendly style and tough immigration policy, has not yet personally reviewed the project, according to the spokeswoman. Rob Worsoff also indicated that he had no interaction with her.
An Explosive Context
This proposal comes at a time of high tension, as the Trump administration has intensified its fight against illegal immigration. The idea of a televised citizenship competition, although intended to be "positive" by its creator, is causing some to gnash teeth and raises ethical questions about the commodification of a fundamental right. This parallel with the world of entertainment resonates all the more strongly given that the current tenant of the White House, Donald Trump, is himself a former reality TV star, famous for hosting The Apprentice, where he eliminated candidates with a merciless "You're fired!".
0 Comments