Sometimes critical of The Lord of the Rings, a work that greatly inspired him when writing A Song of Ice and Fire, George R.R. Martin nonetheless admires this universe. Game of Thrones also has many similarities with Tolkien's world, notably the presence of a great warrior in both cases, Jaime Lannister and Aragorn. In terms of ethics and morals, these characters don't have much in common, but when it comes to swords, they are well above average. During an interview, the American writer named the one he believes would win a duel, and his answer is sure to fuel the debate!
Jaime Lannister, the Lion of Westeros
Before losing his hand in the clutches of Varshé Hèvre, a mercenary from the group Of the Brave Companions, Jaime Lannister was one of the finest blades in Westeros. The son of Tywin and Lyanna is not only handsome, like Aragorn, but also an outstanding fighter. He is the youngest sworn brother of the Kingsguard in the entire history of the Seven Kingdoms, and this is not only due to his father's "connection," whose inestimable wealth opens many doors - and positions. He is an excellent leader of men, and he knows how to inspire the confidence of the soldiers around him. In terms of character, he is courageous, but his bravery sometimes borders on recklessness. Several times, he has brushed with death with disdain, even irony, and his arrogance has already played many tricks on him in the past. Even without his sword hand, he remains capable of defending himself (more than attacking) and he compensates for his disability with intensive training. Apart from the battlefields, not much interests him - except Cersei.
Aragorn, a legendary warrior
In The Lord of the Rings, the mysterious Aragorn is THE warrior figure. He is a Dúnedain, that is to say a descendant of the lineage of Elendil, the founder and High King of the Kingdoms of Gondor and Arnor. His ancestor was murdered by Sauron, Evil Incarnate, during the Last Alliance of Elves and Men. The blood of ancient Numenor runs through his veins: his much longer-than-average lifespan allows him to have far more experience as a fighter than an average human soldier. At the time of the events recounted by Tolkien, he was already around 80 years old, but he retained the strength and vigor of youth. He therefore has both the advantage of age, namely experience and wisdom, without the disadvantage of a tired body. He is also unfailingly courageous. It is said that he survived the Battle of the Pelennor Fields without a scratch.
Jaime VS Aragorn, George R.R. Martin gives his opinion
Ha, if only J. R. R. Tolkien had still been around to debate the issue with George R.R. Martin... The latter declared during a Q&A with fans that it is the Lion of Westeros who would prevail against Aragorn, and here is the reason he gives :
I think Jaime would probably beat Aragorn, especially if he were allowed to wear armor. [...] Armor was invented for a reason. It's good to wear when fighting with sharp pieces of metal.
As you might expect, this bold claim didn't go over well with everyone online! Several chimed in, arguing that "Aragorn is literally the descendant of what could very well be considered a goddess. Melian was one of the most powerful Maiar and her blood runs through his veins" and that "Aragorn also has far more experience with combat and logistics than Jaime will ever have in his lifetime." Others assume that George R.R. Martin isn't serious in his answer, trolling the fan who asked him the question.
0 Comments